|
I recently read the Synthetic-Analytic Dichotomy (Peikoff) and it was a very compelling piece. It did leave me with a question: Does indirectly hearing or reading about something count as a form of experience? The basis: One experiences something and then uses logic to integrate that perceptual data into his existing concepts. It's easy to say this if I look at an apple, and integrate that visual data into my hierarchy of concepts: apples, fruit, etc. I understand where the above idea holds here. If I've never seen or sensed an actual apple in my life before yet somebody describes one to me (truthfully), I do have the concept of the apple but have gained it without directly experiencing the apple. Does this count as experiencing the apple? Albeit, you'll probably have a more detailed concept of an apple if you're able to touch and see it but does the aforementioned count as experience nonetheless? My theory is that this does count as experience. How else would one experience complex mathematical concepts? To deny this is to say that concepts can be formed and integrated without any experience at the root of it. |